Read-a-long with Nintendo Power #253 (April 2010)
March 21, 2010 – 10:40 am | Comments

This issue has some very good news about two games I’ve been monitoring, plus some bad reviews for two games I was going to get. And a little middle-of-the-road news about WarioWare DIY. Stuff your …

Read the full story »
Reviews

Check out what we have to say about the latest, greatest and, er, not-so-greatest games right here.

Articles

We have important things to say. Come listen to us and be awed.

Podcasts

Our podcasts rock. No, seriously. Don’t believe us? Come and check us out if you think you’re awesome enough.

ones to watch

We play a lot of bad games so you don’t have to. Read about what games we think are worthy of your time and money.

read-a-long

It’s like elementary school. Only with video game magazines and no spelling tests.

Home » PC

When Publishers Make You Feel Like a Criminal

Submitted by Joe Haygood on July 28, 2008 – 8:24 pmComments

Sometimes, you have to wonder what a publisher is thinking, as I now know what some people go through when it comes to copy protection. 

Today, I decided to finally buy The Club for the PC, because I had found it at the price point where I was willing to buy it ($29.99).  I had liked the concept of the game, but did not feel it was worth a $50 investment when it first came out.  Now at thirty bucks, I feel the achievements, cross platform play and fun I had with the demo will not go to waste.

Or so I thought.  As you can tell from the picture above, I am not actually playing The Club.  It wasn’t because of me not wanting to play it, but the fact that my version of the game was lacking a CD Key, so I could not get authorized to play the game.

As PC Gamers, we have all heard the story before.  Someone comes into a forum, and immediately asks, “My game shipped without a CD Key, can anyone help?”, to which we all start to jump on the pile and call him a dirty rotten no good pirate, and get out of our forum.  I cannot even count on my fingers how many times I have gone through this as someone that feels there is no way a game could ship without a CD Key.  Until today that is, as I did not get mine with The Club.

So I immediately went to a couple of forums and asked the question about a missing CD Key, to which got me run out of dodge pretty fast, and banned on one forum, until I provided an email with a scanned copy of the receipt, along with the above picture.  Seems that I was getting my just dues, and I had done the same thing to so many people, blaming them for being a pirate, when they may have gone through the same thing.

Only after a lot of Google searching did I finally come across an article, that was in a cached copy of a Sega Tech site that stated that a batch of The Club discs went out without the CD Key being included in the box.  Vindication of me not being a criminal, but why was this not available on the main Sega support site.  It would seem that this would be something you would want available to people considering it just happened recently.  It would have saved me a call to Best Buy (special thanks to the lady that opened a copy over the phone to verify my claims). 

Finally, after much digging, I finally found my issue, but it was in a generic area, and not in The Club support area.  I have submitted for a trouble ticket, and it seems that this must of just happened, as the support page showed a date of June 2008.  I will hopefully have a code in 48 hours, but now I have a game, that I want to play but cannot play, at least for Achievements sake, until the codes come in.  Thank you Sega, for making me feel what it is like to be the villian, instead of performing a bit of quality control on your discs.  If you are having a problem with this, head over to the Sega support form, register and look for an article for CD Key not being in the box.  You will have to submit a trouble ticket, but it will get you a key.  You will also have to submit a copy of the receipt, if you want it to happen promptly.  I assume a manual cover could also do, but I can’t say, as I still had my receipt.  I will follow up when I finally get my code.

  • They send me my key today, because I had included a scan of my receipt. So I did get to play The Club, and I had a lot of fun with it so far. I will have to finish it so I can put up a review.
  • Caid Johnson
    Oops. Stuff happens. You're getting your key, a lot of forum people like to blast others. The gaming world has errors in it. No big surprise.

    It could have been worse though ;)
    At least this way, you'll actually appreciate your new game as the work involved to play it has been the sort which builds appreciation. Pirated software on the otherhand rarely ever (if ever) has that "obtained through hard work" feeling of appreciation attatched to it.

    Caid.
  • paintball745
    yeah they did have a thing going where all you had to do was ask for a silver cd key and they would give you one free no questions asked.i dont think that is live though any more for obvious reasons.
  • Walter
    I'm actually genuinely surprised that none of the forums you went to knew about this. But yes indeed batches of The Club were sent without a cd-key. Now what happened was during the first few weeks when they found out that they screwed up, they came up with a short term fix where anyone who was missing a cd-key would just go on The Club's official site and receive a cd-key providing your email address. Now how would they know who actually bought it and who didn't and is just there to get a free key? They didn't. Rumours then spread that apparently the cd-key you get with The Club works with any other "Games for Windows" (Gears of War, Hellgate, etc). I have no idea if that service is still up or not but if it isn't then that would be a pretty good reason.
  • Stephen
    I used to work at a video game store, and one day I was opening a new copy of Project Gotham Racing 3 to make the gut copy for display, and magically, no disk. Had the manual though. Heard of this on more than one occasion.
  • @ Zac,

    I did call Best Buy, and I talked to a lady that was nice enough to open a copy over the phone, and she found that it had no key in it either. I mentioned this in the article.

    Also, it is funny that the Sega knowledgebase now has the entry for missing CD Key under The Club. It also says to not return it to the store.
  • Zac
    Maybe you should have just returned it to Best Buy for one with a key? It likely would have been faster and stopped you from being flamed (why would you ask knowing that would happen anyway?).
  • Bill
    Well Joe, sounds to me like the publisher isn't making you feel like a criminal, your own peer group is. Maybe instead of complaining about quality control on a box & disk in it, you should be commenting on how jaded your online world has become.

    That said, I do agree that if Sega is aware of the problem, it should not be buried on the web site, but active & up front about providing keys with proof of purchase.
  • Wille'em
    Sounds like Joe and Stephen's co-worker both got lucky. Too bad you didn't get a free game for your troubles.
  • StephenJMunn
    I'll top you. A co-worker received Call of Duty 2 for PS2 some time ago as a gift (it was new) and when he opened the box it was COMPLETELY EMPTY. The gift giver didn't have the receipt, and had paid cash so Target couldn't verify the sale. He called Sony and then finally Activision, who told him yes, occasionally this happens, and that they would replace his copy.
blog comments powered by Disqus