Apple »

Tiny Diggers – An iPad Construction Truck Game for Kids Age 2-5

February 20, 2012 – 12:39 pm | 3 Comments

Tiny Diggers has just been released on the iPad and soon the Mac computer. Here’s the details on this fun, educational game from TouchTilt Games.
Tiny Diggers Delivers Learning With Construction Trucks For Kids on the …

Read the full story »
Home » Industry

The ESRB Will Set You Free!

Submitted by on December 11, 2006 – 12:53 pm5 Comments

esrb_200612.jpg


This weekend I was out shopping for my uncle’s Christmas present at a big box retailer and when I was about to leave the PSP aisle I noticed a familiar holiday occurrence: A parent or relative of a gamer, crumpled list in hand, looking a bit lost, scanning the titles and trying to find something, anything the kid wants so they can leave and go look at DVDs or CDs again.

I volunteer to help, and it’s like I’ve thrown a rope to a drowning person. This woman was happy to get some help.


“It’s for my nephew,” she said, looking at the printed email from her sister, “he wants Grand Theft Auto Liberty City Stories or NHL 07 for his PSP.”

The nephew is 15, and I said that while I’ve been a very big fan of the GTA series, she should be careful about buying it for him. I give the woman a very quick primer on the ESRB ratings, pointing out games rated E, E 10+, T, and M, along with the descriptors on the back of the boxes giving details. She was taken aback by the list of sins below the M rating on Liberty City Stories, and opted instead for the NHL game.

I’m over 18, why care about the ESRB?

Last week Senators Lieberman and Clinton voiced their support for a new set of ESRB public service announcements. While they won’t be in the ads (whew), their support for them is a turnaround for these two vocal critics of the games industry. Astute readers will recall them leading the pack of wolves howling for blood back when Rockstar embarassed themselves and insulted us with their Hot Coffee excuses. I’m very happy to hear that these Senators are getting behind the ESRB. This is a good thing for all of us.

Why should those of us who can play all the M-rated games we want care? Because if the ESRB fails or is beset by regulations and Congressional demands that doom it to fail under an impossible mandate — as recent attempted laws have tried to do — then it will crumble and be replaced by hard and fast regulations and outright censorship. Once Congress is involved you can bet that nobody will go on record voting against stopping content that anyone anywhere deems objectionable.

And could you imagine the court cases that would result from trying to understand legal definitions of today’s E, T, M, and AO ratings?

I admit the ESRB isn’t perfect, and I have my own thoughts on how to improve it, and with luck it will evolve to be a better system. But for now, it’s the best we’ve got and frankly it’s almost completely under the radar of the game-buying public. How can we dispose of something entirely when almost nobody buying games even knows it’s there?

So next time you see a parent struggling to get games from a list for a child, niece, or nephew, or next time you see a mom or dad getting fooled by their 10-year-old child into buying a Rated-M game, lean over and politely clue them in to the rating system. After all, it’s not just going to help them make a slightly wiser game-buying decision, it’s going to help you have a more vibrant and diverse game industry.

  • James

    The ESRB has no one to blame but themselves for the lack of understanding of their rating system.

    If they really wanted people to understand the ratings system, they should have rated them similarly to the MPAA.

    The ESRB decided to be deceptive instead, tagging adult titles with “M” instead of “R”. Movies rated “R” can no longer be blockbuster hits because it blocks out a huge number of teen viewers.

    Games rated properly would suffer the same fate.

  • 11440

    You cannot be serious. The ESRB ratings system is transparent. The “MATURE 17+” label that appears above the “M” is perfectly clear. If parents don’t even read the ratings, that’s their fault. The real problem is that parents want Congress to legislate kid-inappropriate content into oblivion because they can’t be bothered to screen what their children are exposed to. Alarmist parents are at once oversensitive and irresponsible, and opportunistic politicians know that they can appeal to these parents by preying on scapegoats for youth misbehavior.

  • Travis

    rming parents so that when they go out to buy a game they don’t totally overlook the rating of the video game. They should air commercials or somehow put the word out for parents to see a bit more. But, because they don’t, the politicians get to the parents first, cursing the ESRB and saying that the ratings are ineffective. Then the parents take a corrupt stance on the rating system without knowing everything about it because they have only heard the politician’s biased view. Which, leads to unfair criticism.

  • Travis

    Heh, sorry. The beginning to my last post: You can’t shift blame completely onto the ESRB, politicians or parents. The ESRB should be better informing…

  • Nathan

    They really need to change the labels on the ratings though. Honestly, would you buy a game for a 15 year old if it was rated Adult? By all definitions of the AO rating, GTA should be adult rated. M isn’t harsh enough to keep parents away. I think the ESRB did their job well. There were ads on TV, magazines, newspapers even on movies talking about the ESRB ratings and their point trying to make parents understand why they exist.

    The problem is that parents fail. Parents simply don’t care and Clinton and Lieberman know that. For this reason they need to push it further. I think if they simply changed the ratings to be more harsh maybe it would get a better grip on what parents are willing to let their children play. Honestly only adults should be playing highly violent games. Only adults should be playing anything more violent than Call of Duty.
    I think us older gamers need to pay more respect to ESRB and what they try to do. Keep our video games from complete censorship. It’s either beat sense into parents or we don’t get violent games anymore and eventually the government outlaws it.